Reviewing StatisticsThe numbers behind my academic services: how much I review, when, how long my reviews are, and how my scores compare with the final decisions. The full list of venues and roles is on the Academic Services page. SummaryConference manuscripts – venues, cycles Journal manuscripts – journals Workshop reviewing – editions Reviewer recognitions – top / outstanding / best Organizing & AC roles – chairs, area chair Time spent reviewing – estimate Manuscripts reviewed in total: –.
Journal reviews are cross-checked against my ORCID record (synced from Web of Science and Elsevier). Last updated –.
Reviewing per YearCumulative conference reviewing; ★ marks reviewer recognitions (hover for details).
Review KarmaPer year Cumulative Compared to the CommunityReviews per year – – This year – – Review-to-publication ratio – – Sources: The State of Peer Review in Empirical Software Engineering (2026), How Many Papers Should Scientists Be Reviewing? (Publications, 2020), Web of Science reviewer metrics.
Review SeasonReview LengthAverage review length – words per review Average words by venue-year Every review, by year What I Get Asked to ReviewTitle words of papers I reviewed Title words of my own papers Reviewer CalibrationMy score vs. the final decision Agreement with the final decision by venue-year (%) How I Score Each CriterionReview TurnaroundAssignment to submitted review – – Average – – How long I take Every review, by year Career LadderRoles by year: reviewing at the bottom, organizing and chairing above, reviewer recognitions on top. Cell = number of venues; hover for names.
Service TimelineOne row per venue: • reviewer or PC member, GC / Web / SC / AC organizing and area-chair roles, ★ reviewer recognition. Hover a cell for the track or role.
All reviewing by venue (area = manuscripts) Journal reviews by publisher (area = reviews) Reviewer RecognitionsEvery conference venue-year as a point (papers reviewed that year); gold diamonds are the ones that earned a reviewer recognition.
Journal Reviewing in DetailInvitations – – Invitations accepted – – Submitted on time – – Turnaround – – What happened to every invitation What I recommended On time or late, by journal |